What is a Nonsuit and Why They Now Scare Plaintiffs’ Lawyers

Real Estate, Land Use & Construction Law

What is a Nonsuit and Why They Now Scare Plaintiffs’ Lawyers

Aug 24, 2009 | Real Estate, Land Use & Construction Law

Virginia can be a difficult forum for plaintiffs. One tremendous advantage to plaintiffs, however, has been the “nonsuit”. So long as there are no cross-claims or counterclaims filed, a plaintiff has an absolute right to request a dismissal without prejudice and has a right to re-file their case. This statute in essence gives a plaintiff the chance to take a mulligan during the case so long as the case has not been sent to a jury or a dispositive motion is under the advisement of the court.

Statute of limitations concerns are integral to exercise of the nonsuit. The Code of Virginia at § 8.01-229(E)(3) states:

[I]f a plaintiff suffers a voluntary nonsuit … the statute of limitations with respect to such action shall be tolled by the commencement of the nonsuited action, and the plaintiff may recommence his action within six months from the date of the order entered by the court, or within the original period of limitation … whichever period is longer.

A new case from Loudoun County Circuit Court may make exercise of the non-suit and re-filing of the new case a far scarier proposition for plaintiffs. A plaintiff filed and non-suited a personal injury case that requested $325,000 in damages in the complaint. When the plaintiff re-filed the new case, the complaint asked for $500,000 in damages. The court found that because the damages requested had changed, the plaintiff did not “recommence” her “action” as required to gain the benefit of the tolling of the statute of limitations. As a result, the court found the personal injury claims were barred by statute of limitations and dismissed the entirety of the case with prejudice.

This is a trial court decision and is thus not controlling on other courts. It will be very interesting to see if other courts follow this ruling or if the ruling stands up in the face of further motions in the case or appeals. The ruling has already triggered negative commentary and reaction from the plaintiffs’ bar seen at Virginia Lawyer’s Weekly. One thing is certain – whether in a construction litigation context or elsewhere, the case is a clear cautionary tale of how risky and unpredictable litigation can be. Parties in litigation need to keep the upside and downside risks in mind throughout the entire process.

Image: Peter Hellebrand (phelle)


Follow us on LinkedIn to view the latest blogs from our team.

About – Business Insights

Our business blog focuses on issues affecting Virginia, D.C. and Maryland business owners as well as those in other jurisdictions throughout the country. We provide timely insight and commentary on federal and state rules and how they affect you. If you are interested in having us cover a specific topic, please let us know.

About – Employment Law

As employment law constantly changes, the attorneys at Bean, Kinney & Korman stay up to date on the law as it develops. Our blog topics focus on those changes and what you need to know about them, ranging from severance agreements and the FLSA to social media in the workplace and recent court decisions. If you are interested in having us cover a specific topic, please let us know.

About- Real Estate

This blog focuses on real estate, land use and construction-related topics affecting Virginia and the Washington, D.C. metro area. With topics ranging from contract drafting and negotiation to local and regional land use project updates, the attorneys at Bean, Kinney & Korman provide timely insight and commentary on the issues affecting owners, builders, developers, contractors, subcontractors and other players in the industry. If you are interested in having us cover a specific topic, please let us know.

Fairfax County Signage Shake-up

Whether you are demonstrating your support for your favorite political candidate, sharing the day’s specials at your restaurant, or showcasing the location of a major office tenant, you’re undoubtedly using signage to get people’s attention. The who, where, when, and...

The Missing Middle

Arlington County’s Planning & Housing study “The Missing Middle” has entered its second phase, “Analysis & Draft Framework.” The initiative has garnered attention from homeowners, homebuilders, and community members who are interested in how the plan might...